Amelie CameronI admit that I like to treat myself to a luxury item or two—usually, bags, but I love fancy clothes, too. Unfortunately, I can’t afford these luxuries, at least at their full price. Which is why now, I go to a consignment store first!
Thankfully, Toronto has many consignment stores. I’ve visited a few, and they come in a wide variety. Some are basically vintage shops offering old-school items I can’t find anywhere else, while others are fashion stores with discount Prada and Gucci stuff.
In the mood for a shopping spree? Here are some of the best consignment stores in Toronto.
How much do items from a consignment store cost in Toronto?
The price of items being sold in consignment stores in Toronto varies depending on a few factors, such as the item’s condition and brand. As a general rule, the items are priced at less than about 20% to 70% of their original retail price.
How We Chose
Luxury Finds Consignment
Address: 1560 Avenue Rd, 2nd Floor
Operating Hours:
- Monday to Friday—10:30 am to 5 pm
- Saturday—10:30 am to 4:30 pm
Luxury Finds Consignment is aptly named because, yes, this store offers pre-loved luxurious items!
The best part is that they thoroughly evaluate every item, ask the sellers to provide supporting documentation like receipts, and even hire Entrupy, a reputable independent authenticator. So, you can rest assured you’re getting the real deal.
This store may specialize in luxury items, but they do carry a wide array of products—from designer handbags to statement jewelry and clothing. Everything is beautifully organized. Sometimes, I just come here to browse instead of buying.
I also love the customer service here. Everyone is patient and more than happy to provide any documentation when I ask about a product’s authenticity. Because of the wonderful staff, the shopping experience is a breeze.
That said, some customers had a subpar experience purchasing things from their online store. One told me that she didn’t know that her purchase didn’t go through until she asked about it. She wished the store had informed her.
Customer Reviews
Beautifully curated
“I recently discovered Luxury Finds Consignment, and I’m honestly blown away by the experience from start to finish. Not only is everyone there a GEM, but their lunch lives, prompt responses to inquiries and in person shopping experience is amazing! Of course, can’t stop at that! The boutique is beautifully curated, with a wide selection of authentic luxury items ranging from designer handbags and shoes to statement jewelry and clothing. Every item I looked at was in pristine condition — some even brand new with tags! I have left with Gucci purses, Chanel earrings, Fendi Sunnies, Gucci sandals, Louis wallets and so much more! I Introduced a friend and they’ve purchased LIKE NEW condition Chanel bags (yes multiple!! That’s how good it is) – what an amazing experience it has been to shop at LFC! They truly define luxury from the customer service to the purchase and received goodies!.”
- Jaanam Desai, Google Review
Patient and professional staff
“The selection at LFC is incredible – they consistently curate both rare vintage gems and current, on-trend designer bags. I recently purchased a bag from them, and the entire experience was excellent. The team was so patient throughout the process, answering all of my questions with care and providing helpful details that made me feel like a truly valued customer. Their professionalism, authenticity guarantee, and genuine passion for luxury fashion really set them apart from other consignment boutiques. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend LFC to anyone looking for a trusted source for special pieces, whether you’re searching for a timeless classic or something more unique.”
- Myanca Rodrigues, Google Review
Second Nature Boutique Mount Pleasant
Address: 514 Mt Pleasant Rd
Operating Hours: Tuesday to Saturday—12 pm to 6 pm
Contact Number: +14164814924
Second Nature Boutique is conveniently located in the Mount Pleasant West neighbourhood, with a few bus stops nearby.
The selection here is pretty good. You can find not just clothes like tops, bottoms, dresses, and jackets, but also accessories, shoes, and bags. Sometimes, there are even houseware items, which always take me by surprise (in a good way).
In terms of brands, there’s a nice variety as well. I like that they both have luxury (e.g., Gucci and Louboutin) and mid-tier brands (e.g., Zara and Guess).
I have to commend the staff here; they’re eager to help. One time, I was having a hard time trying to style a pair of Valentino sandals, and the staff helped me out. I felt like I was in one of those makeover montages you see in movies!
The prices here are already amazing, but you can score even more discounts during special holidays like Black Friday and Cyber Monday! Just beware, though: this store gets crowded during these special sales.
Do take note that this store doesn’t accept returns. So, make sure that you truly want to purchase the item you’re eyeing.
Customer Reviews
Great selection, friendly staff
“Love this consignment shop! Great selection, fair prices, and everything is beautifully organized. The staff are friendly and helpful — always a fun place to browse and find unique pieces!”
- Shuo Zhang, Google Review
Amazing conditions for a great price
“Honestly, one of my favourite places to shop in Toronto. All the girls — Jenna, Marianna, Phiso — are phenomenal and just want to help style you and put you in something you’ll love. I’ve been such a consistent shopper here for a couple of years now and as a lover of vintage and designer, you’ll find both here in amazing condition for a great price. (Whoever got these red Manolo’s that were a little too small for me, I’m so jealous).”
- Ksenia Kazantseva, Google Review
Mine and Yours
Address: 79 Yorkville Ave
Operating Hours:
- Monday and Tuesday—10 am to 6 pm
- Wednesday to Saturday—10 am to 7 pm
- Sunday—11 am to 6 pm
Contact Number: +14378808264
Mine and Yours carries all sorts of fashion products—clothes, shoes, bags, accessories, and jewelry. They even have menswear items available, which I’m thrilled to discover.
The brands featured here are diverse. They have your usual consignment shop staples like Gucci, Hermès, Jimmy Choo, and Louis Vuitton, but there are also ones I don’t normally see like Maison Margiela, Ula Johnson, and Alaïa.
The staff is also amazing—friendly and knowledgeable about fashion. One time, I told a staff member that I was feeling a certain kind of style, and she worked with me in selecting which items fit my vision. I greatly appreciated that.
If you really want to score more steals, you’ll be delighted to know that they often have clearance sales, usually held by the end of the season. The discounted prices get even more reduced, so don’t miss out on them!
Unfortunately, this store doesn’t accept order cancellations. They also won’t refund you for returned items, but you can get store credit for them or have them exchanged for something else, so long as you return the item within 15 days of purchase.
Customer Reviews
Excellent customer service
“I had an amazing first shopping experience at this beautiful store and left with a pair of Fendi boots that not only were in almost brand-new condition, but also at a significant reduction from their retail price! Linh was very helpful and friendly while assisting me and Sophia coincidentally was wearing the same pair- the perfect model! I’m so excited to style my new purchase and highly recommend Mine & Yours for their wide variety of designer finds, as well as their excellent customer service!”
- Diane Qi, Google Review
Kind and well-versed staff
“I decided to check out this beautiful store after hearing about it since I love a quiet luxury moment. I was on the hunt for a dress with an event coming up and was impressed by how kind and well versed the staff were. A big shoutout to Linh for working 1:1 with me during my visit and intuitively selecting styles that aligned with what I was after. Such a nice experience overall. Side note, I loved the fitting room lighting!”
- Jenny, Google Review
Fashionably Yours Designer Consignment Boutique
Address: 707 Queen St W
Operating Hours:
- Monday to Wednesday—11:30 am to 6 pm
- Thursday and Friday—11:30 am to 6:30 pm
- Saturday—11 am to 6:30 pm
- Sunday—12 pm to 6 pm
Contact Number: +16478029687
Fashionably Yours is another boutique shop that will appeal to designer brand lovers. This shop only carries products from designer brands, and they even make sure to authenticate the items before selling.
The lineup of brands here is impressive. They have Prada, Alexander Wang, Calvin Klein, Cartier, Dolce and Gabbana, Gucci, and so many more. Seriously, I’ve come here multiple times, and I still get surprised when I see another designer brand!
Customers commend the customer service here. One shared that she actually managed to negotiate the price for a bag, but unfortunately, she had to cancel because of the high duty/customs fee (she’s from the US).
The staff allowed her to cancel the order, which surprised her because many consignment stores don’t do this!
Another great thing about this shop is its location. It’s right by downtown Toronto, so you can reach it via bus or metro, no problem.
While many customers have a great experience here, some don’t. One told me that she tried to contact the staff for a specific item multiple times, but she didn’t get any response.
Customer Reviews
Great customer service
“Their customer service is great. One of the associates worked with me on getting the best price for a bag I wanted. I unfortunately asked to cancel the bag because I was concerned about high duty/customs fee (I’m in the US) and they kindly let me cancel the order. If I’m ever in Toronto again I will definitely stop by as they have a great selection and are really willing to work with their customers.”
- Suzanne Ross, Google Review
Great attention to detail
“Incredible attention to detail. The customer service was great, you can tell they didn’t care about the sale, they cared about if i left wanting to come back or not. Highly recommended.”
- Aaron Alleyne, Google Review
VSP Consignment
Address: 1410 Dundas St W
Operating Hours:
- Monday to Saturday—10 am to 6 pm
- Sunday—12 pm to 5 pm
Contact Number: +14165889821
VSP Consignment is one of the most popular consignment shops in Toronto, and I can see why. In addition to its convenient location in the city’s West End, the product lineup is amazing. There are even fashion items for both men and kids here!
They have a more curated selection of designer brands, which some may find limited. Personally, I don’t mind it because I like what they have.
The staff is the reason most customers love coming here. They’re accommodating, patient, and thorough. You can even book a personal shopping appointment if you need help bringing your stylish vision to life.
However, one thing I don’t like about VSP Consignment is the lack of organization.
One time, I was looking for a pair of pants that came with a blazer (it was listed as available on the website), and when I asked a staff member, he told me that the pants were already sold. They should update their online inventory often.
Customer Reviews
Great variety of items
“I found some amazing things here, such a great variety of items. The staff were incredibly helpful from start to finish, and the store is beautiful, clean, and organized. I personally don’t understand any of the complaints in the reviews about organization. It’s a consignment shop, not a department shop – not everything will be in perfect order. Great shopping experience.”
- Asena Firouzi, Google Review
Exceptional experience
“I am absolutely thrilled with my recent online purchase from VSP. I have purchased pre-loved items for years, and there have been some disappointments when items have arrived in less than desirable condition, despite being graded as a 9/10 by the consignment company. I have to say I have never been so pleasantly surprised with a purchase. The Gucci bag I purchased is immaculate, it was packed so beautifully, with such care, VSP truly goes the extra mile for their customers. Thank you so much for an exceptional experience.”
- Nicole Stephenson, Google Review
